She Paved The Way
Written by Mark Schubin
In ever-changing New York, it’s remarkable that the five stops on On Site Opera’s The Road We Came Lower Manhattan Tour remain largely as they were. Two other locations in the area, not stops on the tour but near the route, played a significant role in Black music history but are unrecognizable today. They are the sites of the last two concerts of the first U.S. tour by Elizabeth Taylor Greenfield.
She was born into enslavement on a plantation in Natchez, Mississippi. It’s not clear when she was born; different documents suggest 1817, 1819, or 1826. She received both her first and last names from the wife of her enslaver, Elizabeth Holliday Greenfield.
After the death of the plantation mistress’s first husband, Jesse Greenfield, and the divorce of her second, Elizabeth H. Greenfield moved to Philadelphia. The young girl, no longer enslaved, went with her. Elizabeth Taylor was her name when she was enrolled in Philadelphia’s Clarkson School.
The elder Greenfield provided for the younger in her will, but disputes prevented the latter from receiving any inheritance after the woman’s death in 1845, so Elizabeth T. Greenfield established herself as a music teacher. In 1851, she went to Buffalo, New York, where she performed at a soiree covered by the local press.
The most-famous singer in the U.S. at the time, thanks to promotion by showman P. T. Barnum, was soprano Jenny Lind, known as “the Swedish Nightingale.” Perhaps as an avian comparison, the Buffalo Commercial Advertiser headed its October 10 review of Greenfield’s performance “A Black Swan!” The description stuck. Black Swan Records, the first successful Black-owned label, was later named for her.
After a number of sold-out concerts in upstate New York, one with Lind’s piano accompanist, Greenfield took on Barnum associate James H. Wood as manager and embarked on a tour from Vermont to Wisconsin, including Toronto and Hamilton, Ontario, in Canada. She played at many of the same halls as Lind and stayed in many of the same accommodations. Lind heard Greenfield perform and encouraged her career. The last stop of the tour before Greenfield left for Europe was New York City.
In anticipation of Lind’s arrival in New York in 1850, brothers Archibald Brown Tripler and William Creighton Tripler built a music-performance venue on Broadway at what is now West 3rd Street, with a capacity of 5,000, to be called Jenny Lind Hall. Although it wasn’t finished in time for Lind’s New York debut, Barnum still advertised that Lind would open her eponymous hall. But a different soprano, Anna Bishop, did, and the name of the venue changed to Tripler’s Hall. Lind eventually performed at Tripler’s Hall, and so, too, after its name changed to Metropolitan Hall (shown at left), did Elizabeth T. Greenfield.
Greenfield had frequently confounded her audience’s expectations. A review of one of her concerts in the Daily Free Democrat (Milwaukee) on April 21, 1852 said, “We see the face of the black woman, but we hear the voice of an angel.” Her repertoire was wide ranging. It included English, Irish, and Scottish ballads; opera arias by Balfe, Bellini, Donizetti, Verdi, and Zingarelli; an aria from Handel’s Messiah; a hymn, and other songs. She was said to have had an extraordinary vocal range. Sometimes she accompanied herself on piano.
The poster for the concert at New York’s Metropolitan Hall (right) said nothing about audience restriction, but newspaper ads did: “No colored persons can be admitted, as there is no part of the house appropriated for them.” Even so, according to The New York Times the next day, “Several letters were sent to the manager threatening dire disasters to the building, if the dark lady were permitted to sing. Consequently there was a great parade of the Police force in the lobbies and in the body of the house. Fortunately, however, their services were not called into requisition.”
Greenfield apologized to the city’s Black community for their having been barred from her concert and said she would “with pleasure sing for the benefit of any charity that will elevate the condition of my colored brethren….” That concert took place a few days later at the huge Broadway Tabernacle (left) between Catherine and Worth Streets. Later the same year, Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth each addressed assemblies at the same church building. After the concert, Greenfield sailed for Europe, where she soon gave a command performance for Queen Victoria.
The Broadway Tabernacle closed in 1857, after being purchased by the Erie Railroad. Its site is now occupied by a nondescript apartment building called Saranac (right). The congregation still exists as the Broadway United Church of Christ on West 86th Street.
Metropolitan Hall burned down in 1854, was rebuilt (and briefly named the Metropolitan Opera House), burned down again in 1867 (by which time it was called the Winter Garden), and was replaced on the site by a small hotel and then a larger one, said at its opening to be the largest in America. Baseball’s National League, for which Jackie Robison later played, was founded there in 1876. The hotel changed names several times before partially collapsing in 1973. It was replaced by Hayden Hall (left), a residence for NYU’s law school.
There is a small historical plaque on the Broadway façade of Hayden Hall. It commemorates the founding there of the American Society of Heating and Ventilating Engineers.
On Site Opera’s The Road We Came walking tours ensure that it’s not just engineers who try to inform the public of the histories of forgotten locations. The five stops on the Lower Manhattan tour and the other 11 stops on the Midtown and Harlem tours cover far more than just one person’s contribution to the history of Black music in New York City.